Do loyalty programs cost? Of course, like all initiatives, campaigns or enterprises a company puts in motion. But, boy oh boy, can they deliver ROI. In fact, loyalty programs are among the cheaper ways to grow. Keep the customers you paid to acquire, get them to come back more often, and watch revenue climb without the ad bill climbing along with it.
But for a lot of online brands, that’s not quite how it’s playing out. Spending keeps going up, while the margin story gets a little fuzzier every quarter. PwC’s 2025 Customer Experience Survey puts numbers on that frustration. 84% of executives say they’ve increased spending on customer loyalty, yet 57% admit their programs aren’t delivering the expected outcomes.
That gap rarely comes from one bad call. It usually comes from a handful of habits that look harmless on their own but, as they compound, quietly eat into profit. So we put together five of the most common ones, and what to do about each.
Mistake 1: Making blanket discounts the main reward
We shoppers are price conscious, no question about it. Thus, for brands, the easiest ecommerce loyalty program to launch is “members get 10% off.” It’s also the one most likely to hand margin to customers who would have bought anyway. In the same PwC survey, 69% of consumers say comparing prices significantly influences whether they engage with a brand. But answering that with storewide markdowns mostly teaches members to wait for the next code.
Personalization changes the math. In a McKinsey’s research on combining loyalty and pricing, companies running personalization pilots saw a two to four percentage point improvement in gross margin dollars compared with standard mass offers.
A few ways to get there:
- Point rewards at the products you actually want to move, like priority SKUs, bundles or overstock, instead of the whole catalog
- Swap some straight price cuts for bonus points, free shipping thresholds or early access to new products
- Use purchase history to decide who gets which offer, so the incentive shows up where it can change behavior
Mistake 2: Counting members instead of measuring what the program adds
Careful with vanity KPIs. A growing member count looks great in a board deck, but it says very little about whether the ecommerce loyalty program pays for itself. The 2025 Deloitte Consumer Loyalty Program Survey found that the average consumer is enrolled in eight programs but actively participates in only five.
In other words, a good slice of your “members” may be little more than names on a list. The measurement problem goes deeper than that. PwC found that 83% of executives say they need better tools to measure what drives purchases. Without those tools, it’s hard to tell loyalty you created from loyalty you simply paid for.
The fix is to judge the program by incremental results. Compare enrolled and non enrolled customers on repeat purchase rate, average order value and lifetime value, and hold out a small control group when you launch a new offer. If a reward costs more than the extra margin it brings in, it’s a perk for your customers and a cost for you, nothing more.
Mistake 3: Making rewards slow to earn and easy to forget
A points balance that never seems to get anywhere is a buzzkill. Merkle’s 2025 Loyalty Barometer Report found that 33% of customers who abandoned a loyalty program in the past year did so because rewards took too long to earn. Deloitte adds another wrinkle: 40% of members say they sometimes forget to redeem.
Unredeemed points can look like savings on paper, but members who never feel the value tend to drift. And drifting is getting easier. A BCG’s global loyalty survey showed consumers are 5% to 10% more inclined to consider switching to another program in the same category than they were two years earlier.
Keep the program moving by giving members an early win within their first purchase or two, letting them earn for actions beyond buying (reviews, profile updates, referrals) and sending automated nudges by email, SMS or WhatsApp when they’re close to a reward.
Mistake 4: Keeping loyalty data apart from the commerce stack
Many online brands run their ecommerce loyalty program as a side system that talks to the storefront once a day, if that. The result is offers based on yesterday’s data, rules that need a developer ticket to change and a lot of manual reconciliation behind the scenes.
The Underutilized Superpower Hidden in Loyalty Data, a Forrester Consulting study published this year, shows how widespread this is. 68% of the loyalty and marketing decision makers surveyed said, for example, their loyalty data is only partially integrated with other systems at best, and just 26% said their programs are very effective at delivering value.
When the program lives inside the commerce platform, earning rules can follow SKU, category or order value, and members can see their balance and progress right at checkout. That’s the idea behind Fielo’s ecommerce loyalty program , which connects natively to Salesforce Commerce Cloud and also supports storefronts such as Shopify, Magento and BigCommerce, so business users can launch and adjust promotions without waiting on IT.
Mistake 5: Copying the B2C playbook for B2B storefronts
Brands that sell online to distributors, dealers and wholesale buyers often borrow retail mechanics wholesale (pun intended). Points per dollar for each individual user sounds fine until you remember that B2B purchases are made by buying groups, on negotiated pricing, and mostly as reorders.
Rewarding one buyer ignores the account that actually holds the budget. A better setup usually includes:
- Account level tiers based on cumulative online order value or product mix
- Rebates and reorder bonuses tied to quarterly targets, calculated automatically
- Rewards for moving orders from phone and email to the portal, plus points for training or trying new product lines
These mechanics push buyers toward the channel that’s cheapest to serve, which helps margin twice: once on the order and again on the cost to process it.
Protecting margin starts at the design stage
Most of these mistakes share a root cause. The program was built to make customers feel rewarded, and nobody went back to check whether it made the business more profitable. The good news is that value isn’t only about price.
Deloitte’s research suggests up to 40% of a brand’s perceived value comes from factors other than price alone. In our view, trust and relevance are two other elements that cannot falter. All that leaves plenty of room for rewards that feel generous without giving away the store.
As for the ecommerce loyalty program, start with an honest audit. Which rewards drive incremental orders, which ones are subsidizing purchases that would have happened anyway, and how quickly does your data reach the place where offers are decided? Answer those three, and you’ll know where your margin is leaking.


































Leave a Reply